Bengals/Raiders Trade LordSummerisle64: ok so it's tommy kane and shawn lee
LordSummerisle64: for
LordSummerisle64: raiders 1993 4th round pick and pierce holt
LordSummerisle64: do you agree?
bpkcchiefs: i agree
LordSummerisle64: ok i'll post
BENGALS RECEIVE:
DL Pierce Holt
Raiders 1993 4th round pick
RAIDERS RECEIVE:
DL Shawn Lee
WR Tommy Kane
I agree.
sowa1291- 01-15-2008
Is this a fair trade?
A stud DL for a crappy one and then an average wr for a 4th rounder?
What do you guys think?
MRTECMOSUPERBOWL- 01-15-2008
Is this a fair trade?
A stud DL for a crappy one and then an average wr for a 4th rounder?
What do you guys think?Shawn Lee is average not crappy plus he is young. Also Tommy Kane may be BkpChiefs best receiver now. I feel it is a fair trade that is my opinion! Holt is old and about to retire!
LordSummerisle- 01-15-2008
Holt is 30 and could go anytime, as I found out the hard way with Bruce. Unless he finds himself among the sack leaders at DL he has at least a 50% shot of aging every year from here on out.
Kane is 27 and 38ms/56rec, debatably the Raiders' best receiver (56rec makes him tied for their best REC) and fills a major need for that team whose backup receivers are atrocious and the starting WR aren't much better.
Shawn Lee is young (24) and 56hp.
Not sure I see what the issue is. I certainly didn't feel I was ripping BPK off in this one, like I did after the Anderson/Graddy trade.
sowa1291- 01-15-2008
My mistake I thought Holt was much younger.
LordSummerisle- 01-15-2008
Holt just a rental until STRAHAN becomes a Bengal next year! Dreams can come true.
brookstonfowler- 01-15-2008
would you like to keep "lightning holt" or would you like me to change it back to good ol' pierce?
bpkcchiefs- 01-15-2008
haha...thats easy...lord will want peirce
Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.
